Allstate vs Progressive
Numbers refreshed
For Allstate and Progressive, the figures cover state-guide prices, market share, satisfaction and financial strength.
Compared side by side
| Allstate | Progressive | |
|---|---|---|
| US market share rank | 4th (10.2%) | 2nd (18.6%) |
| J.D. Power satisfaction | 4 of 11 regions above average | 1 of 11 regions above average |
| AM Best rating | A+ (Superior) | A+ (Superior) |
| Discounts listed on its site | 4 | 5 |
| Safe-driving app | Drivewise | Snapshot |
Source: Insurance Information Institute, Facts + Statistics: Auto insurance (NAIC data via S&P Global Market Intelligence); AM Best press release (news.ambest.com); J.D. Power 2026 U.S. Auto Insurance Study press release.
Which one costs less
State rate guides priced 755 profiles in states where both sell, and Progressive came out cheaper 548 times out of 755.
Your price may be different, since each company weighs age, record and car in its own way.
| State (adult, clean record) | Allstate a year | Progressive a year |
|---|---|---|
| Colorado | $5,112 | $2,680 |
| District of Columbia | $1,710 | $1,404 |
| Florida | $2,655 | $1,796 |
| Maryland | $4,423 | $2,964 |
| North Dakota | $726 | $476 |
| Oklahoma | $2,190 | $2,012 |
| South Carolina | $817 | $814 |
| Texas | $912 | $651 |
Source: Colorado Division of Insurance (DORA): Auto Insurance Premiums Report (Ins_Survey_Reports, AUTO); DC DISB: 2024 Auto Premium Comparison 08-15-2024 (Sample Profiles, 6 month policy); Florida Office of Insurance Regulation: CHOICES Auto Rate Comparison Tool (county rate data /PandC/Data/CountyRates); Maryland Insurance Administration: Auto Insurance: A Comparison Guide to Rates (As of August 2026); North Dakota Insurance & Securities Department: 2026 Auto Insurance Cost Comparison Survey; Oklahoma Insurance Department: Auto Insurance Rate Comparison (Updated September 2026); South Carolina Department of Insurance: Price Comparison Tool, Sample Auto Rates (SampleRates.aspx?Id=Auto results); HelpInsure.com Auto FAQ (TDI).
Get prices for both
More comparisons
- GEICO vs Progressive
- Progressive vs State Farm
- GEICO vs State Farm
- Allstate vs GEICO
- USAA vs State Farm
- Farmers Insurance vs State Farm
- Liberty Mutual vs GEICO
- USAA vs GEICO
- Travelers vs Progressive
- American Family Insurance vs State Farm
- Nationwide vs Progressive
- Erie Insurance vs State Farm
- Root Insurance vs GEICO
- Lemonade vs GEICO
First written