Compare Car Insurance Companies
Figures refreshed
Big insurers are compared for share, satisfaction, strength and price.
Pair-by-pair comparison pages
- GEICO vs Progressive
- Progressive vs State Farm
- GEICO vs State Farm
- Allstate vs Progressive
- Allstate vs GEICO
- USAA vs State Farm
- Farmers Insurance vs State Farm
- Liberty Mutual vs GEICO
- USAA vs GEICO
- Travelers vs Progressive
- American Family Insurance vs State Farm
- Nationwide vs Progressive
- Erie Insurance vs State Farm
- Root Insurance vs GEICO
- Lemonade vs GEICO
Companies in our comparisons
| Company | US share rank | Share | AM Best |
|---|---|---|---|
| State Farm | 1st | 18.7% | A+ |
| Progressive | 2nd | 18.6% | A+ |
| GEICO | 3rd | 11.6% | A++ |
| Allstate | 4th | 10.2% | A+ |
| USAA | 5th | 6.2% | A++ |
| Farmers Insurance | 6th | 3.6% | A |
| Liberty Mutual | 7th | 2.8% | A |
| Travelers | 8th | 1.9% | A++ |
| American Family Insurance | 10th | 1.5% | A |
| Nationwide | A | ||
| Erie Insurance | A | ||
| Root Insurance | |||
| Lemonade |
was when this was first written.